See how Malarkey Highlander, Vista and Legacy compare on impact classifications and standard warranty periods, with a practical roof-selection checklist.
Malarkey’s architectural range offers three useful starting points. Compare the impact rating and standard early warranty period before choosing the look for your home.
Compare at a glance
| Product | Impact class | Standard non-prorated period |
|---|---|---|
| Highlander | Class 3 | 10 years |
| Vista | Class 4 | 15 years |
| Legacy Scotchgard | Class 4 | 20 years |
Vista and Legacy both carry Class 4 classifications. Legacy has a longer standard non-prorated period in this comparison. Check the exact variant: algae coverage differs between standard, AR and Scotchgard products.
Look beyond the sample
Tree cover changes how a shingle color looks from one roof plane to the next. Compare Highlander, Vista and Legacy samples in both sun and shade; this project photo is illustrative, with its manufacturer unverified.
View full-size samples beside your brick, stone, siding and trim. Confirm local product and color availability before ordering.
Try Malarkey’s official Roof Designer and color selector
Four questions for your estimate
Is the quoted product Highlander, Highlander AR, Vista, Vista AR or Legacy Scotchgard?
Which colors can the local supplier provide?
Does the installation qualify for standard or enhanced wind coverage?
Is an enhanced certified-contractor warranty actually included in the proposal?
The finished roof also needs to work around walls, penetrations and intersecting slopes. Ask how those details are included in the installation scope. This is a construction-detail reference, not an identified Malarkey roof.
Keep the coverage specific
The manufacturer’s current written warranty controls coverage. Product defects, wind, algae and workmanship have different terms. Enhanced coverage requires verification of contractor credentials, products and registration. A portal account or pending application is not certification.
Compare the complete roofing system
See our roof replacement service
Request a written comparison for your roof
Manufacturer resources
Prepared by Barnes N’ Roofs. Product information checked September 17, 2026.